Emily Todt M.A.
© privat
  • Dissertation Project

    Magic, Fraud, and Truth.
    Court Proceedings in Bavaria, Saxony, and Württemberg, 1760–1840

    The idea of the doctoral project is based on the observation that, during the Enlightenment, magic was increasingly dismissed as “superstition” in legal and scientific discourse and ultimately classified as fraud. As a result, the possibility of magical efficacy was legally contested, while the everyday use of magic as a means of orientation, information gathering, or protection remained widespread. Building on this tension, the project analyses the courtroom as a social arena in which competing claims regarding the truth – the legal-normative impossibility of magic and its claimed effectiveness in everyday life – were communicatively negotiated. Specifically, using a comparative approach to Bavaria, Württemberg, and Saxony, the project examines how the possibility and efficacy of magic were discussed in court, how they were legitimized or contested, and what processes of negotiation and clarification can be identified in this context. The study examines linguistic, argumentative, and performative strategies employed by defendants, courts, and witnesses to establish, contest, or undermine credibility. The focus of the research lies on strategies of evidence and any practices of ridicule through which competing truths were stabilised or delegitimised.

    The period under examination, from 1760 to 1840, encompasses the decisive phase in which the criminal-law assessment of magical practices experienced a fundamental shift. While magic was still punished in the first half of the 18th century on the assumption that it actually possessed magical efficacy, this notion increasingly lost its plausibility in the second half of the century. Magical practices were no longer regarded as a matter of course as the manipulation of hidden cosmic and sacred forces, but increasingly as acts of deception that had to be rationally refuted and legally redefined. The definitive classification of magical practices as fraud was established by 1839.

    Supervisor: Prof. Dr. Ulrike Ludwig

  • CV

    Academic Education

    since 07/2026 Ph.D. fellow
    at the Gerda Henkel Foundation
    since 04/2026 Doctoral studies in Early Modern History
    University of Münster
    2023–2025 Master of Arts in History 
    University of Münster
    2019–2023 Bachelor of Arts in History and Art History
    University of Münster
    2017 Abitur at the Gymnasium Bad Nenndorf
    Bad Nenndorf

     

    Occupational History

    2025–2026 Research assistant in the project “Private Letters from the Thirty Years’ War – The Westphalian Context”
    University of Münster, Institute for Comparative Urban History
    2022–2025 Student assistant at the Käte Hamburger Kolleg “Unity and Diversity in Law”
    University of Münster
    2022 Student assistant at the Chair of Early Modern History (Prof. Dr. Ulrike Ludwig)
    University of Münster, Department of History
    2022–2023 Student assistant to Dr. Jana Weiß, Chair of Modern and Contemporary History with a Special Focus on North American History
    University of Münster, Department of History
    2020–2022 Student assistant in the project “Prophecy in a Local Context” (led by Prof. Dr. Ulrike Ludwig)
    University of Münster, Department of History
    2017–2019 Apprenticeship as an Industrial Management Assistant
    Martin Braun Backmittel und Essenzen KG, Hanover