By
Kim Rahn
Staff Reporter
The Seoul Central District Court on Tuesday sentenced
Korean-German scholar Song Du-yul to seven years in
prison for violating the National Security Law.
``A heavy sentence is inevitable as Song worked as a
member of the North Korean ruling Workers Party
Politburo and had a bad influence on the countries¡¯
peaceful unification by spreading the Kim Il-sung¡¯s
ideology in the South,¡¯¡¯ the court said in the ruling.
Presiding judge Lee Dae-kyong said Song¡¯s Politburo
membership is proved by statements from Hwang Jang-yop,
former secretary of the North¡¯s ruling party, and former
North Korean diplomat Kim Kyong-pil.
Song¡¯s claim that joining the workers¡¯ party was
merely a formal procedure to enter the communist country
was rejected, as the North extends the party membership
only to those faithful to the ideology, the court ruled.
``He provided theoretical basis for Kim Il-sung¡¯s
ideology to spread in the South with academic writings
and contributions leaning toward the ideology, and
helped raise pro-North organizations. Freedom of study
and conscience can be limited for national security and
order,¡¯¡¯ Lee said.
However, the court acquitted Song on charges of
entering North Korea to hold academic meetings,
considering that he was not the main organizer and the
meetings were legal.
It also found him not guilty on charges of making a
silent prayer at a North Korean office in Berlin in July
1997 commemorating Kim Il-sung¡¯s death, as it was done
overseas and Song is a foreign national. Another charge
of helping pro-North people in South Korea enter the
communist country between 1989 and 1999 was also
dismissed for lack of evidence.
``It is partly reasonable that he can be judged a
victim of a divided country. He came back to the South
despite the expected punishment, and the society should
acknowledge his academic achievements.¡¯¡¯
``However, we pass down a heavy punishment, as
joining the workers¡¯ party is a serious violation of the
security law. He has kept denying his activities and
shown no regret over his pro-North academic
activities,¡¯¡¯ the court said.
Song¡¯s lawyers said they will appeal to a higher
court, saying the seven-year sentence is too severe and
the ruling didn¡¯t have firm criterion as it found him
guilty on academic activities, but acquitted him on the
charge of holding academic meetings.
The prosecution, which earlier demanded a 15-years
prison term, also opposed the court ruling. It said it
can¡¯t accept the not guilty verdict on charge of holding
meetings and that the sentence is too light.
Song was indicted on the charges of violating
National Security Law by joining the North¡¯s ruling
party and working to spread the communist ideology, as
well as visiting the country 22 times from 1973 until
last year for Kim¡¯s funeral and academic
meetings.